Free Article Home l  Submit Article l Contact Us


Medjugore, Signs and Wonders   by A K Whitehead 

Medjugore, Signs and Wonders
by A K Whitehead

An article by Francis Frangipane has recently gone into circulation. It is
a very balanced and well constructed article. The main
purpose was to argue the need to put the word of the Bible
before signs and wonders and to see the latter in the context of the
former. He made a number of useful points and used some interesting
concepts. It was of a quality one would expect from him no more than
one would expect from him and it is not my purpose here to criticise
this work.

However, there are some points which arise from what he
said which do need attention. In pursuing his objective he, inevitably,
made comments which were subservient to it and, not being of main
concern, were not developed. But some of these do require further
consideration.

Extra-biblical Phenomona
FP defines manifestations which have no pattern in the Bible as
extra-biblical. In these he includes the quaking of Quakers and the
rolling of Holy Rollers. He then includes the claimed visitations of the
mother of Jesus at Medjugore (in the former Yugoslavia) as belonging
to the same category. This is surely a slip of thought.

Medjugore Patterns in the Bible?>/B>
A pattern consists of elements which can be regarded as representative
of something and which are repeated in recognisable ways.

In fact, there are several well known instances in the Bible which
constitute a pattern into which Medjugore fits very well. Visitations
of angels abound,
but there are other instances: Samuel appeared to Saul, albeit illegally
(1 Samuel 28:8 - 20); Jacob had an encounter with a heavenly being
(some would say divine) (Genesis 32. 23 - 33); there was a (probably
divine) appearance to Joshua (Joshua 5. 13 - 15). Of course, we know
of the appearance to Jesus himself of Moses and Elijah (Matthew
17. 1 - 8f) and there are many other examples one could quote.

Do these constitute a pattern into which the (claimed) appearances at
Medjugore fit? Surely they do. The visions at Medjugore are different
in only two respects: they concern a female rather than a male figure;
and they have been repeated every night without fail over twenty-two
years. Otherwise, and these are surely not grounds for exclusion, the
Medjugore events fit into the biblical pattern extremely well.

True, as patterns go, are identical, but many have repetitions which
include nonidentical elements. This is evident when we compare such
biblical events as mentioned above. All have similarities of one kind
or another but none can be said to be identical.

Medjugore, Quakers and Rollers.
The events at Medjugore cannot, therefore, properly be compared
with extra-biblical charismatic-type events relating to such as Quakers
and Rollers. Of course, Francis Frangipane was simply looking for
some examples, and unfortunately picked on Medjugore. But, since
the latter can be seen quite clearly to fit within the biblical category,
it does demand further attention. Clearly, this kind of categorisation
is permissive rather than conclusive of its genuineness: everything that
looks like something biblical is not necessarily genuine.

At least because of its influence on very large numbers of people, not to
say that God may be reaching to these people through this
manifestation, the Medjugore phenomenon warrants some further
consideration.
Divine Or Demonic Origin?
FP says I personally do not believe that this was (is?) Mary. He
does not say why but, as we have noted, thinks that God may be using it.
But that is not really enough. It is either of satanic or of divine origin.
One or the other. Ought we not to make an assessment of which?

Is there a possibility of satanic origin? That is doubtful when one
considers the messages, and I have read many of them, which have
been coming out of Medjugore since 1981. Jesus once asked
“How can Satan drive out Satan?” because a kingdom or house
cannot stand if divided against itself. Moreover, he added, very
significantly, that, if Satan were to oppose himself, his end would have
come (Mark 3. 23 - 26f).

Now, it may well be that Satan’s end is near, but it has clearly not
arrived at the moment. Moreover, the essence of the conflict between
God and Satan is, to coin a phrase, a struggle for the hearts and
minds of God’s people. In that conflict the major weapon is a
composite of words, concepts and ideas - a major weapon on
both sides.

So what are the words (and fruits) coming out of Medjugore?
Principally, and repeatedly over the past twenty-two years: love,
peace and prayer - and not just any prayer, but sustain, repeated,
serious, two, three hours of prayer every day; the establishments of
prayer groups and a renewal by thousands of their life in Christ. Now,
does that sound like a message from Satan? Hardly. For as yet, his
kingdom has not fallen. Certainly he is a crafty strategist, but he
would hardly take the risk of repeating these messages every day for
so long! And to what end?

So phenomena at Medjugore is unlikely to be satanic in origin. That
leaves a divine source. FP doubts it is Mary. But who else, then?
Has God sent some angelic spirit to give such words of truth, over
so long a period, by deceiving his people with a spirit instructed to
claim to be the mother of Jesus but which it is not? That seems
implausible, to put it at its lowest.

Hence, whether we like it or not, (but why do we not?) Mary seems
the likeliest probability.

Now, although a lifelong Catholic, (albeit with strong Pentecostal
symptoms) I am not what Catholics would call a Marianist
i.e. someone with a special devotion to Mary. And I have always been
somewhat shy of the idea of to Jesus through Mary>/I> - not
because it cannot happen, because it can and has for many people,
but there is always the risk getting stuck on or at Mary.
But maybe that implies that I think God cannot look
after those who sincerely seek him.

However, we also have to take a wider view than Medjugore itself.
It has been argued here that the (claimed) appearances there are not
extra-biblical and that is not surrendered. But suppose they were,
for arguments sake. While the Bible contains only truth, not all truth
is contained within the Bible.How could it be when John’s gospels
says that the world could not contain even everything which the
disciples knew of Jesus alone (John 21. 25)?
Being extra-biblical, as WP acknowledges, is not in itself a cause for
condemnation. So...?

In order to accept that the appearances at Medjugore are genuine,
one has to consider them within the wider framework of Marian
appearances. Medjugore is only the latest in a long cycle of (claimed)
appearences of Mary. Most non-Catholics will not be aware of
even those in the modern era, which amount to at least eight major
visitations, from Guadalope in Mexico in 1531, through Bernadette
Soubirous in1858 at Lourdes in France, andKnock in Ireland in
1879, to Fatima in Spain, in 1917 (which led Catholics world-wide
to pray over decades for the downfall of communism and the USSR).
Not one is identical to another but there is a very strong pattern of
similarities (which space here does not permit of description).

In every instance there have been signs and wonders over succeeding
decades or centuries of continuing evangelistic and healing associations.
Far too many to delineate here, but far too many to pass-off as
bunkum and, for reasons similar to those given above, too
marked by the work of the Spirit to judge satanic in origin.

I have never been to Medjugore. Perhaps I should have. But, in FP’s t
erms, I could have been found running after signs when the
Toronto Blessinghit the north east of England at Sunderland
some years ago. I hope I did not do it at the expense of the God’s
word. But I could not accept the condemnations which some other
Christians were making of it of it without investigation. I did get the
shakes as a result, although I could never see any real
spiritual growth as a consequence.

There is, perhaps, too much suspicion among Christians of Christians
in sectors other than one’s own (not that Francis Frangipane is guilty
of this). God is too big even for the Bible, and certainly for
our limited minds to comprehend. And it is surely an irresponsible
Christian who thinks he knows the limits to the ways in which God
acts among his people, or who thinks he can impose such limits.


Author Info:

About The Author:A K WhiteheadWeb Site: www.christianword.co.uk. Email: akw@christianword.co.ukExperience: Over twenty years in Christian healing, teaching and writing.Qualifications: B.A., M.Phil., Camb Univ Cert in Religious StudiesThis article may be reproduced on condition that it is unaltered and that alll this information is included.

 
30 Most Recent Articles :
A Disputed New Business:Virtual Property Exchange

In many ways, the in-game economy is similar to a real world economy - goods and services are traded to mutual advantage and are mediated in currencies(gold,platinum,credit,etc.). An online broker, who goes by the screen name Rolala, was not a fan of online games until his 15-year-old son be[ Read Article]

THE UNITED STATES, A Terrorist Nation

I love the United States of America, but I cannot tolerate the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. No I am not shouting at you, I am simply making a distinction, a difference that thirty-seven states of the union have noticed and moved to rectify. You see, AMERICA isn’t America anymore, nor does it in anyw[ Read Article]

Dollars and Sense

When I speak of the Federal Reserve and the fiat monetary system that controls our lives I feel as though my words are falling on deaf ears. I have the sense that the simplest conversations suggesting that change must be made invoke fear and condemnation from my fellow citizens. When will we tak[ Read Article]

Constitutionality

Is the 16th Amendment constitutional? Of course it is, the Supreme Court has made that as clear as it did the issue of slavery. But let us remember that it took the lives of more than 365,000 brave American men and the destruction of the Republic to wrest the matter from the courts and resolve the[ Read Article]

Five Secrets to Effective Pay-Per-Click Advertising

With so many companies swarming the World Wide Web with their products, how can you and your products and services stand out? Your ready answer would most likely be effective marketing. But how? How can you catch the eye of a surfer skimming carelessly through web pages? How can you keep the at[ Read Article]

How to Sell Bonds

If you want to make good money with banks, or any institution, Government and agency bonds are where it is at. Simply because all Government bonds and agencies are AAA rated, and banks can buy millions of dollars of any bond without incurring any credit risk. All banks own bonds of some sort, a[ Read Article]

Closing in the Car Business

The “P” Word. Closing is all about helping car customers make positive decisions. It is not about pressure or manipulation. Your customers need help overcoming the “P” word. Procrastination! Procrastination is natural when it comes to making a buying decision. Your customer is trying to avoid [ Read Article]

If You Build It They Will Come, or Will They?

All right, so you invested your time and energy to build your organization a great new web site, but you are not getting quite the results you were hoping for. Few customers are visiting or interacting with you and rarely do you get prospects to contact you through the site. So what can you do to [ Read Article]

Confessions of a Yoga Teacher

The following are questions that Yoga teachers still need to answer, despite overwhelming evidence that Yoga is ?the mother of all health maintenance systems.? Mainstream thought is finally catching up, with the progress Yoga is making, but it has taken 5,000 years for us to get this far. Serio[ Read Article]

Vertical Creep in Search Results :: Should Organic Optimizers be Concerned?

I thought for this week I’d give a summary of some of the more interesting Search Engine Strategies sessions which are currently going on in New York City. I was at SES as a speaker last year in New York and I have to say, there is a wealth of information there even if some of it is contradict[ Read Article]

How to build link popularity fast and free

We all knew that back link or link popularity is a big factor to get good position in any search engines. But building link popularity some times really hard if you don't know how to do it. One of the hardest problem for new webmasters is to get back link to their newly stablis[ Read Article]

Does Chiropractic Care Really Make Sense?

The Role of Chiropractic in Treatment Beyond the Resolution of Symptoms Do you have the same nagging injury that never seems to go away? Are you suffering needlessly with pain? Are you fed up with taking painkillers? Do you want to find out what is causing your pain? If your answer is ‘ye[ Read Article]

The Economic Implications of Buying Drugs Online

Although the Internet is fairly new (at least to the mainstream) online shopping has grown by leaps and bounds. Now you can buy almost anything you need, from food to fishing equipment, right through your computer. Of course, this has meant that commerce has been forced to adapt to the changing co[ Read Article]

Manning and Manning-Can Either Brother Win the Big One?

It was just over a year ago, after the Colts lost to the Pats in their post-season contest, that Boomer Esiason said on national television, "I think maybe Peyton (Manning) is this generation's Dan Marino." Esiason went on to state that Manning "is a great football player, but he's not going to get[ Read Article]

Branding, Branding, Branding - MSN fails to keep it Straight

Sometimes you see promotions come along and you wonder: did they just do that? The current MSN promotion called msnsearchandwin is a prime example of this. Not only do they use “black hat” or at least “questionable” tactics on the site, but the messaging is inconsistent. In this article [ Read Article]

The New MSN Search Interface :: A positive change or the antithesis of transformation?

Now, instead of wide blue bars there are sleek silver-grey bars. Also, the top bar where the search box is became narrower. To me this makes the page seem less “closed in” and more visually appealing. I now feel as if I can trust the results more because they have more room. I’ve also noti[ Read Article]

Malta Holidays

With Malta visitor numbers static in recent years and facing new competiton from former Eastern Bloc countries offering cheap holidays, the recent announcement by the Maltese government that negotiations were at an advanced stage with two low cost airlines has[ Read Article]

Drug Rehab Treatment Centers as an Experience, not a Punishment

Choosing a drug rehab treatment center is a decision that calls for both negative and positive emotions. Nobody wants addiction to overtake their life to the point that rehab is the necessary step. However, the decision to go to one is something to look forward to, as it is the decision to rebui[ Read Article]

Some ways to improve your king content

There are thousands of articles, books and forum posts which showed that content is king in search engine optimization (SEO). In this article, you can find some ways that can help you improve this king content for your web site. * Content for people first, not for search engines - Some webmaste[ Read Article]

Aerosmith Just Keeps On Rockin’

For over three decades, Aerosmith have been one of rock's most revered and popular bands, crafting classic songs full of raw guitar runs and intensely energetic vocals. The band first reached fame in the 1970’s with a string of hits including "Dream On," "Sweet Emotion" and "Walk This Way." During t[ Read Article]

Chicago Cubs Pitcher Mark Prior Re-signs

After many trips through the rumor mill, Mark Prior accepted the Chicago Cubs’ offer on January 27 to a one-year, $3.65 million contract. That is $900,000 more than the salary he would have earned under the contract he voided in November. Since Prior's definitive season in 2003 (18-6), he has cooled[ Read Article]

Social Networking - The Next Great Marketing Medium?

There has been a virtual explosion of social networking sites in the past couple of years. Even the big players like Google, Yahoo and MSN are getting into it. With so much interest in how social networks work, one begins to wonder if there is marketing potential within these social network[ Read Article]

How to choose paid directory for web site listing?

How to choose paid directory for web site listing? Search Engines are the major source of traffic for any website. High search engine ranking can boost number of your visitors and in turn leads to increase in sales. The best way to get top search engine placement is to improve link popularity [ Read Article]

Addiction Treatment Centers Using Experiential Therapies

Life is experience. Substance dependence overtakes a person’s ability to make her own decisions to experience life, and life is no longer actively participated in. Therefore, in overcoming addiction, it is vital to learn to re-experience life. This lesson helps a treatment center resident reint[ Read Article]

The DH: Making Life Tough for AL Pitchers

In 1973 Major League Baseball instituted three rules designed to lessen the power of pitchers and create more offense. One theory at work was that the game needed to be energized and that more hitting would create additional runs and excitement. Both the National and American Leagues lowered th[ Read Article]

Vacation on the Beach the Smart Way

Vacation on the Beach the Smart Way Almost everyone agrees; there is no more relaxing way to vacation than to take it to the beach. For the vacationer/traveler who hasn't considered a beach house rental before, they represent an affordable and fun family oriented alternative. There is an intell[ Read Article]

Malta Holidays and Hotels Buzzed by New Jets

With Malta visitor numbers static in recent years and facing new competiton from former Eastern Bloc countries offering cheap holidays, the recent announcement by the Maltese government that negotiations were at an advanced stage with two low cost airlines has sparked hopes that the island will see [ Read Article]

The Rising Cost of Prescription Drugs

If you’re like many Americans, the rising cost of prescription drugs may be costing you your health. In particular, seniors living on a fixed income with no insurance are finding it difficult to pay for necessary prescriptions out-of-pocket, and as a result, may be failing to receive the treatment[ Read Article]

Who's Tops in Hockey and Who's Not

The National Hockey League needs to do more to encourage better coverage of the hockey games. With so many other sports realizing national coverage, the NHL is sometimes forgotten. However, this year, there's a race for the Stanley Cup, and only one is set to win it. But which team will that be? [ Read Article]

The Danger Of Rounding Up Your Debts

Rounding up your debts is one of the biggest dangers to your financial position. It's also one of the easiest ways for your debts to get out of control. This way of thinking is best summed up by the following comment; ‘I already owe $27500 so what’s another $500. It takes my debt to a nice round [ Read Article]

 
World Top Stories :
XML error: not well-formed (invalid token) at line 7